5. Appeals Policy
In2assessments are committed to providing a high-quality learning experience for all their apprentices and undertake to treat each apprentice fairly and consistently.
Fairness to all employers and apprentices is central to this policy and we are committed to quality assurance processes that are based on impartial, evidence-based judgements. However, all employers and apprentices are entitled to enquire about, or appeal against, assessment or other decisions.
The purpose of this policy is to make sure that employers and apprentices know how they can enquire about EPA, or appeal against an outcome of an EPA. The policy is also intended for use by In2assessment staff to ensure that all enquiries about results and appeals are dealt with consistently.
Enquires - Enquiries from apprentice / employer that is not satisfied with an assessment result that has been set and marked by In2assessments
Appeal of the final grading decision awarded by In2assessment
Appeal of results on the basis that In2assessment did not apply procedures consistently or that procedures were not followed properly and fairly
Appeals from an apprentice that is not satisfied with the outcome of the employer’s internal appeals procedure
Appeals from employers or apprentices relating to an In2assessment decision to decline a request to make reasonable adjustments
Appeal from employers that disagree with the outcome(s) from assessors
Appeals from employer or apprentices in relation to the outcome of an investigation into a report of malpractice and / or maladministration including sanctions imposed
Appeals from employer or apprentice of bias or discrimination in the assessment and grading
Out of Scope for Appeal
The following cannot be appealed:
Appeals submitted more than 30 working days after the key date
Dependent on the nature of the appeal, the key date may be the date at which an employer’s internal appeals procedure concluded, or when a In2assessments auditor reported their decision, or when a final grade decision was reached
Events / activities that took place before In2assessments received the employer selection letter and received the apprentice registration details
Anything that should be dealt with under and employer’s own disciplinary or grievance procedure
Anything involving an awarding organisation of regulated qualifications that have been delivered as part of the apprenticeship (either mandatory or non- mandatory)
Anything involving the apprenticeship on-programme delivery and activities.
Where an employer believes that either they or an apprentice has grounds for an enquiry or an appeal to In2assessments, they should submit it in writing and addressed to In2assessments, Skern Lodge Appledore, Bideford Devon EX39 1NG or via firstname.lastname@example.org
All initial review and / or appeals will be acknowledged within three working days. Employers and apprentices have 30 working days from the key date to lodge an appeal with In2assessments.
If an employer appeals on behalf of the apprentice the employer must ensure that it has obtained the written permission of the apprentice(s) concerned as results can go down as well as up as a result of an investigation i.e. a pass mark could go down to a fail mark.
When submitting an appeal, relevant supporting information must be supplied such as:
Employer name, address and contact details
Apprentice’s name and unique learner number
Key date(s) the employer or the apprentice received notification of a decision
Date an assessment took place
Whether a remark or an administrative check is required
Title of the apprenticeship affected
A clear statement of the grounds for the enquiry and / or appeal i.e. full details of the nature of the appeal including any evidence that is relevant to the appeal and, where an employer internal appeal has taken place, the outcome of any investigation carried out relating to the issue and the documentation relating to that appeal (in the case of an assessment appeal, this may include the apprentice’s work, records of assessment, internal quality assurance and the internal appeal)
The appellants name, position and signature
When an apprentice’s knowledge assessment results vary considerably from the result they expect, the apprentice may make an enquiry about the assessment result to In2assessments. An enquiry about results is a formal request, in writing, for a review of a knowledge assessment result. An employer may make an enquiry about a knowledge assessment result on behalf of one or more apprentices. Apprentices should discuss their case with their employer before a request is made. It is only possible to request an enquiry for an assessment that is marked by In2assessments.
A request can be made either for an administration check, or for a re-mark. A fixed fee is charged when a request is made for this service. The fee is refunded if the outcome of the test or assessment is changed as a result of the enquiry.
On receipt of the appeal, the responsible officer (or EPA Manager) will convene a panel made up of two senior members of In2assessment staff not involved in the circumstances surrounding the appeal, and that have no personal interest in the outcome of the review or appeal decision.
The panel will undertake an initial assessment of the potential appeal to ensure the application is complete within the scope of the policy, and to ascertain if the issue can be resolved before it goes to a formal appeal. A In2assessment associate who is independent of the matter under review may provide specialist knowledge input to the panel.
If the request falls within the scope of the policy the appellant will be notified within five working days.
The panel will consider the evidence submitted and, if necessary, request additional information be provided before reaching its conclusion. The panel will consider whether the required procedures were followed correctly and whether they were applied fairly, consistently and properly in arriving at judgements. The panel will recommend either the appeal is:
The recommendation will be confirmed to the appellant within 10 working days.
If the review upholds the appeal, the apprentice or employer will be advised of any actions required to conclude matters and any fees will be refunded
If the review does not uphold the appeal, the apprentice or employer will be told that they may make a formal appeal to the Independent Appeal Panel
Independent Appeals Procedure
If an appeal has not been upheld at the review stage, the appellant may request in writing that an appeal be passed to In2assessments’ Independent Appeal Panel for decision. The written request to In2assessments responsible officer (or EPA Manager) must be made within 10 working days of the notification of the review, re-mark, appeal or administrative check decision.
All requests will be acknowledged within 4 working days of receipt.
In2assessements Independent Appeal Panel is made up of a member of the senior leadership team, a subject specialist that has not been involved in the original appeal and an independent person that is not employed by In2assessments, or in any other way connected to the organisation that has the appropriate knowledge and skills to decide on the subject matter.
The panel will convene within 10 working days of the request being received by the responsible officer. The panel will evaluate all the evidence submitted and decide if In2assessments has applied the procedures fairly, appropriately and consistently in line with In2assessments policy and recommend either the appeal is:
The decision of the Independent Appeal Panel is final. All decisions will be communicated to the Chair of the Governing Board.
Notification of Outcome of Appeal
The apprentice or employer will receive formal notification of the outcome within 21 working days of the start of the independent appeal process:
If the appeal is upheld, the apprentice or employer will be told of any actions required to conclude matters and fees will be refunded
If the appeal is not upheld the apprentice or employer will be given the reasons in a report
The employer will be notified of any subsequent actions
All initial reviews, appeals and subsequent outcomes are reported to In2assessment Governing Committee. The appeal and its outcome will be used to inform our self-assessment and self-evaluation activities and will feedback into our EPA development and review process where necessary.
Independent Appeals Panel Terms of Reference
In2assessments Independent Appeals Panel shall consider and determine appeals submitted to it by those wishing to challenge a decision or decisions reached during the appeals process.
In2assessments Independent Appeals Panel is made up of a member of the senior leadership team, a subject specialist that has not been involved in the original appeal and an independent person that is not employed by In2assessments, or in any other way connected to the organisation that has the appropriate knowledge and skills to make a decision on the subject matter. A member of In2assessments administrative team shall be present at each meeting of the panel to take notes of the meeting but shall not be involved in the appeal proceedings.
Proceedings of Meetings
The panel may appoint advisers to provide advice at the meeting, but they will not be involved in the decision-making process of the appeal outcome.
The panel shall convene when necessary to ensure that appeals are heard promptly. This will usually be within 10 working days of the appeal being received by the Head of In2assessments.
At each meeting of the panel all members must be present for the proceedings to be valid, except in the event of exceptional circumstances outside the control of the panel or any member.
The panel will review the original appeal decision and any further evidence provided by the appellant as part of his / her request for an appeal to ensure that procedures were applied consistently, properly, and fairly.
The panel may request additional information from the centre / learner, arrange discussions with centre staff and / or visit the centre if necessary.
The Chair may, at their discretion, adjourn or suspend proceedings for any such period as the Chair deems reasonable if the additional information is not readily available or arrangements need to be made to visit a centre.
The Chair of the panel will notify the appellant, in writing, of the panel’s decision within 20 working days, and the Chair of the governing body.
All notes of the proceedings shall be evidence of the appeal and must be kept securely in In2assessments electronic information management system for a minimum of 3 years
5. Management of personal data
The apprentice’s submission, and all accompanying statements and records, will be kept confidential as far as is possible in facilitating a fair and thorough review. Whilst the apprentice’s privacy and confidentiality will be respected, this needs to be balanced with:
• The need for an open and fair investigation
• Appropriate remedial action to be taken
• The outcome of the investigation to be reported appropriately
• Action to be taken to improve our processes and quality of service.
The details of the apprentice’s submission may, therefore, need to be shared with others who have been involved with the assessment process and are responsible for their design and delivery.
The ultimate responsibility for the EPA Complaints and Appeals policy, dissemination of the policy and management of the complaints and appeals rests with the In2Assessments senior management.
Resolution will be on the basis of ensuring a fair and safe outcome for patients, the apprentice and their employer.
In some cases, it may be necessary for In2Assessments senior management to seek advice from the EPA’s external quality assurer.
7. Quality improvement process
In2assessments undertakes to treat all complaints and appeals that fall within the scope of the policy respectfully. Regardless of the outcomes of complaints and appeals, all such submissions shall be reviewed to elicit any learning to inform improvements in In2Assessments policies and procedures.
Outcomes of complaints and appeals shall be recorded and reviewed by In2Assessments senior management team for reflection and inform the quality improvement process.
If the apprentice is not happy with the outcome of the complaint/appeal then they should be advised to escalate it to the Education & Skills Funding Agency through the apprenticeship helpdesk on 0800 150400 or by email email@example.com